The WP Popup Maker alternative that builds and tests campaigns for you.

WP Popup Maker gives you a plugin to host and maintain. OptiMonk’s AI Agent gives you campaigns that are built, tested and tied to sales, fully hosted.

Start for free See the full comparison

Free to start. No credit card.

G2 support reviews

104vs 7 WP Popup Maker

Platforms

Anyvs WordPress WP Popup Maker

AI features

Agentvs None WP Popup Maker

The short answer

A yearly license upfront vs monthly plans that scale with your traffic.

OptiMonk wins 6 of 8 categories. WP Popup Maker wins on price and native WooCommerce.

Pricing & free planWP Popup Maker wins AI featuresOptiMonk wins A/B testingOptiMonk wins AnalyticsOptiMonk wins WooCommerce integrationWP Popup Maker wins Platform supportOptiMonk wins Templates & designOptiMonk wins SupportOptiMonk wins

Feature by feature

WordPress-only vs any platform, side by side.

OptiMonk vs WP Popup Maker: feature comparison
Feature	Start free
Pricing
Free plan	Yes: 10,000 pageviews, 1 domain, all features	Yes: Core plugin free; advanced features are paid add-ons
Starting price (paid)	Partly: $29/mo (monthly billing)	Yes: $59.40 first year, then $99/yr, single site
Pricing model	Info: Pageview-based	Info: Domain-based annual license
Core features
Templates	Yes: No fixed templates. The Agent designs each one to match your brand	Partly: 6 built-in themes, no campaign templates
Campaign types	Yes: Popups, fullscreen, gamification, opt-ins, built with the AI Agent	Yes: One canvas: slide-outs, bars, stickies, lightboxes, tooltips, opt-ins
A/B testing	Yes: All plans incl. free: control group, in-campaign format, static vs. animated, multivariate, set up with the AI Agent	Partly: Possible via custom JavaScript
Built-in analytics	Yes: Revenue-focused Smart Analytics	Partly: Pro plan ($59.40 first year)
Revenue attribution	Yes: All plans	Partly: Pro+ only ($149.40 first year)
AI features	Yes: OptiMonk AI Agent, Dynamic Product Recommendations	No: None
Platforms
WordPress / WooCommerce	Yes: Yes	Yes: Native plugin
Shopify	Yes: Shopify App Store	No: No
Other platforms	Yes: Any site via script	No: WordPress only
Support
Support	Yes: Live chat + email on all plans; AI Agent in-product	Partly: Email support, documentation

Category by category

Where the AI Agent and sales analytics make the difference.

01Pricing & free plan

How does OptiMonk pricing compare to WP Popup Maker?

WP Popup Maker is cheaper. If a basic WordPress popup is all you need and you don’t mind a more time-consuming setup, there’s no reason to overpay. It charges a flat annual license per site; OptiMonk scales with pageviews.

For a growing store that wants AI campaign creation, A/B testing and revenue analytics in one place, without stitching together paid extensions, OptiMonk earns its price.

WP Popup Maker wins

WP Popup Maker wins on price. A flat annual license per site with unlimited traffic is hard to beat if budget comes first. OptiMonk’s free plan lets you try AI, testing and revenue analytics before you commit.

	OptiMonk	WP Popup Maker
Free plan	Yes: 10,000 pageviews/mo, all features	Yes: Unlimited traffic and popups; analytics, exit intent, WooCommerce paid
Entry paid plan	Partly: $29/mo, 20,000 pageviews, 2 domains	Yes: $59.40 first year, then $99/yr, 1 site
Full feature set	Yes: All plans	Partly: Analytics on Pro; revenue & WooCommerce on Pro+ ($149.40)
Traffic limits	Partly: Pageview-based	Yes: Unlimited
Multi-site	Yes: Multiple domains per plan	Partly: Per-site licensing

02AI features

Which tool has better AI?

Popup Maker has no AI. Campaigns are built manually, start to finish.

The OptiMonk AI Agent builds a complete campaign that matches your brand from your domain and a prompt, asking follow-up questions if needed. Describe any change (copy, design, targeting, translation) and it applies it. It sets up tests and suggests improvements, and Dynamic Product Recommendations personalize what each visitor sees. All on every plan.

OptiMonk wins

OptiMonk wins. The widest gap in this comparison: the Agent builds, edits and tests campaigns for you, so there’s nothing to code or design by hand.

	OptiMonk	WP Popup Maker
AI campaign creation & editing	Yes: OptiMonk AI Agent: learns your brand from your site, takes requests in chat, in any language	No: No
Brand-matched campaigns	Yes: The Agent reads your site	No: Manual only
A/B tests set up in chat	Yes: Yes	No: No
Dynamic Product Recommendations	Yes: Yes	No: No
Smart Analytics	Yes: Yes	No: No

03A/B testing

Which tool has better A/B testing?

Popup Maker has no built-in A/B testing, but you can randomly show different popups using custom JavaScript and track results in a separate analytics tool.

OptiMonk’s testing is built in on every plan and set up by chatting with the AI Agent: multivariate tests, control groups, static vs. animated popups and different campaign types against each other within one campaign. Results land in the same dashboard.

OptiMonk wins

OptiMonk wins. No developer needed and all results in one place, so you can run tests yourself and act on them faster.

	OptiMonk	WP Popup Maker
Built-in A/B testing	Yes: All plans	Partly: Custom JavaScript
Test copy, offers, designs	Yes: Yes, via the AI Agent	Partly: Requires custom code
Control group & multivariate	Yes: Yes	No: No
Results in same dashboard	Yes: Yes	Partly: Separate analytics tool

04Analytics

Which tool gives you better analytics?

Popup Maker’s Pro plan adds an Advanced Analytics dashboard for opens, clicks and conversions inside WordPress, and pushes stats to Google Analytics. Revenue attribution needs Pro+ ($149.40 first year, then $249/year).

OptiMonk’s Smart Analytics are on every plan: which campaigns drive revenue, conversions through to purchase, all in one dashboard.

OptiMonk wins

OptiMonk wins. Popup Maker’s Pro plan pushes stats to Google Analytics, a real plus if you work there, but revenue tracking needs Pro+. OptiMonk has revenue analytics on every plan, so you know which campaigns are worth keeping.

	OptiMonk	WP Popup Maker
Opens, clicks, conversions	Yes: All plans	Partly: Pro plan ($59.40 first year)
Google Analytics integration	Yes: All plans	Partly: Pro plan
Revenue attribution	Yes: All plans	Partly: Pro+ only ($149.40 first year)
On free plan	Yes: Yes	No: No

05WooCommerce integration

Which tool is better for WooCommerce?

Popup Maker has a home advantage: as a native plugin, it plugs straight into WooCommerce, with cart, category and purchase targeting handled by extensions inside your WordPress dashboard.

OptiMonk connects to WooCommerce too and covers the core use cases, but runs as external SaaS with a separate dashboard.

WP Popup Maker wins

WP Popup Maker wins for pure WooCommerce stores. It lives where your store lives.

	OptiMonk	WP Popup Maker
Native WordPress plugin	No: External SaaS	Yes: Yes
WooCommerce integration	Yes: Yes	Yes: Via WooCommerce Pro extension
Target by cart value / product	Yes: Yes	Yes: Via extension
Managed inside WordPress	No: Separate dashboard	Yes: Yes

06Platform support

Which tool has better platform support?

Popup Maker is WordPress-only. It doesn’t run on Shopify or via script, and it doesn’t follow you if your business grows beyond WordPress.

OptiMonk works on WordPress, WooCommerce, Shopify and any platform via script, with campaigns and data in one place.

OptiMonk wins

OptiMonk wins. It works on any platform, so you won’t need a new tool if your store moves beyond WordPress.

	OptiMonk	WP Popup Maker
WordPress	Yes: Yes	Yes: Native plugin
Shopify	Yes: Shopify App Store	No: No
Other platforms (script)	Yes: Yes	No: No
Multi-domain	Yes: 2+ domains on paid plans	Partly: Per-site licensing

07Templates & design

Which tool has better design options?

Popup Maker ships 6 built-in themes for styling, with no pre-built campaign templates. Professional results take technical effort.

OptiMonk skips the blank canvas. The AI Agent builds each campaign to match your brand from your domain, from cart abandonment to gamified wheels, using a past popup, a library example or your own image as inspiration. Everything is editable without code.

OptiMonk wins

OptiMonk wins for anyone who isn’t a developer: the Agent designs campaigns to match your brand, so you don’t need CSS or a designer.

	OptiMonk	WP Popup Maker
Templates	Yes: No fixed templates. The Agent designs each one to match your brand	Partly: 6 themes, styling only
Editor	Yes: AI Agent + drag-and-drop	Partly: WordPress editor
AI-generated campaigns	Yes: OptiMonk AI Agent	No: No
Gamification	Yes: Spin-to-win and more	No: No
Mobile-optimized	Yes: Yes	Yes: Yes

08Support

Which tool offers better customer support?

Popup Maker scores a perfect 10.0 for support on G2, from 7 reviews, and reviewers mention helpful responses. Support is documentation and email-based.

OptiMonk scores 9.7 across 104 reviews, a stronger signal at scale. It offers live chat on every plan, with replies under 3 minutes, an AI Agent that helps in the product and an account manager from Premium.

OptiMonk wins

OptiMonk wins. Popup Maker’s support scores a perfect 10.0 on G2 (from 7 reviews), but it’s email and docs only. OptiMonk adds live chat on every plan and replies in under 3 minutes.

	OptiMonk	WP Popup Maker
G2 support score	Yes: 9.7/10 (104 reviews)	Yes: 10.0/10 (7 reviews)
Live chat	Yes: All plans	No: No
Onboarding	Yes: The AI Agent, plus support portal	Yes: Comprehensive docs
Account manager	Yes: Premium plan and up	No: No

FAQ

Frequently asked questions.

WooCommerce, pricing, AI, and how add-ons affect the total cost.

Is Popup Maker cheaper once you add the extensions you actually need?

Often still yes. Popup Maker is WordPress-native, with annual per-site licenses and no monthly fee, well suited to content sites and developers. OptiMonk is SaaS across WordPress, WooCommerce, Shopify and other platforms, adding the OptiMonk AI Agent, A/B testing, product recommendations and revenue analytics.

Is OptiMonk free the same way WP Popup Maker is free?

OptiMonk’s free plan includes 10,000 pageviews a month, 1 domain, unlimited campaigns and all features, including A/B testing, the AI Agent and analytics. It’s not a trial. Popup Maker’s core plugin has no traffic limit but gates analytics, exit intent and WooCommerce behind paid extensions.

Is OptiMonk a good Popup Maker alternative for WooCommerce stores?

Yes. Target by cart value, product category, purchase history and behavior, with cart abandonment popups and product recommendations on all plans. Popup Maker’s full ecommerce features need Pro+ ($149.40 first year, then $249/year).

Does OptiMonk work on WordPress?

Yes. The OptiMonk plugin is in the WordPress plugin directory, installs in a few clicks and works with any theme. WooCommerce integration needs no add-ons.

How do I switch from Popup Maker to OptiMonk?

Sign up free, install the WordPress plugin and show the AI Agent your existing popups: it rebuilds them to match your brand. Bars and slide-outs have no direct equivalent. Run both in parallel, then deactivate Popup Maker when you’re confident. Live chat and the support portal help along the way.

What happens when I hit the pageview limit on OptiMonk’s free plan?

Campaigns pause for the rest of the billing cycle, with no data or settings lost. Upgrading gives you more pageviews and domains with the same features.

Does WP Popup Maker have AI?

No. Campaigns are built manually in the WordPress editor.

What are the pros and cons of OptiMonk vs WP Popup Maker?

Here’s the short version.

Tool	Pros	Cons
OptiMonk	The OptiMonk AI Agent builds, edits and A/B tests campaigns from your domain; works on Shopify and any platform; built-in A/B testing and revenue analytics; free plan to start (10K pageviews)	Separate SaaS dashboard rather than a WordPress plugin UI; pageview limits
WP Popup Maker	Free core plugin with unlimited traffic; low annual per-site license; native WooCommerce inside WordPress	WordPress only; no AI; A/B testing needs custom code; analytics and revenue on paid extensions

Staying on WordPress, but want an AI Agent that builds for you?

OptiMonk’s WordPress plugin is in the directory, with A/B tests and recommendations on every plan.

Start for freeFree to start. No credit card.

The WP Popup Maker alternative that builds and tests campaigns for you.

A yearly license upfront vs monthly plans that scale with your traffic.

WordPress-only vs any platform, side by side.

Where the AI Agent and sales analytics make the difference.

How does OptiMonk pricing compare to WP Popup Maker?

Which tool has better AI?

Which tool has better A/B testing?

Which tool gives you better analytics?

Which tool is better for WooCommerce?

Which tool has better platform support?

Which tool has better design options?

Which tool offers better customer support?

Frequently asked questions.

Staying on WordPress, but want an AI Agent that builds for you?

More comparisons